Trump Administration Proposes Eliminating Schedule A Green Card Path for Nurses, Threatening Rural Hospital Staffing
The Department of Labor proposes eliminating Schedule A, increasing green card processing times for immigrant nurses and potentially worsening shortages in rural U.S. hospitals.
Trump Administration Proposes Eliminating Schedule A Green Card Path for Nurses, Threatening Rural Hospital Staffing The Department of Labor proposes eliminating Schedule A, increasing green card processing times for immigrant nurses and potentially worsening shortages in rural U.S. hospitals. The Trump administration has proposed eliminating Schedule A, a decades-old immigration provision that allowed hospitals to bypass standard labor certification processes when sponsoring professional nurses and physical therapists for green cards. This regulatory shift targets the removal of the expedited pathway, requiring employers to undergo the rigorous Program Electronic Review Management labor market test instead. The Department of Labor stated that it no longer possesses evidence demonstrating a nationwide shortage of United States workers who are able, willing, qualified, and available for these roles. The proposal, which was published on November 17, fundamentally alters the procedural steps employers must complete before sponsoring international healthcare professionals. Under the new framework, hospitals seeking permanent residency for foreign nurses would generally be required to recruit United States workers first. They would then need to obtain individual labor certification from the Labor Department before filing an immigrant petition. This change is part of a broader overhaul of the PERM system designed to strengthen protections for American workers.Keith Sonderling, the Secretary of Labor, defended the proposed rule change in a statement announcing the new regulations. He asserted that American workers are the best in the world and deserve the first and best job opportunities. Sonderling argued that existing regulations had allowed companies to sponsor foreign workers without fully considering American workers first. The administration contends that this new approach will ensure American workers remain first in line for high-skilled, high-paying job opportunities over foreign labor.Health care and nursing organizations have issued strong warnings regarding the potential consequences of eliminating Schedule A. Akin Demehin, vice president of quality and patient safety policy at the American Hospital Association, stated that the change would add substantial costs and administrative burdens to the recruitment process. The American Hospital Association expressed concern that the proposal would exacerbate existing shortages of nurses and physical therapists who are essential to providing high-quality care in communities across America.Michelle Canero, managing partner at Canero Fadul Reis PLLC and a board member of Immigrants List, highlighted that the administrative consequences could be significant for healthcare providers. She noted that each nurse case would add more than a year before the green card petition can even be filed. This extended timeline strains institutional resources, particularly for smaller facilities. Canero emphasized that small or independent rural hospitals often lack the resources necessary to comply with the new rule requirements. These smaller institutions are also the employers least able to absorb vacant shifts while they wait for the extended certification process to conclude.Jerome Babate, executive director of the Filipino Nursing Diaspora Network, provided further context on the impact of these delays. He explained that in a small hospital, even a few prolonged vacancies can affect how many beds it can staff or which services it can offer. The labor market for international recruitment is already evolving, with TruMerit reporting an observable decrease in visa applicants over the past two to three years. Simultaneously, internationally educated nurses have made up an increasing share of the healthcare workforce in Europe and Southeast Asia, reducing the pool of potential candidates for United States positions.Data from a June 2026 KFF analysis of federal data shows that immigrants accounted for 17 percent of healthcare workers in 2024. The Philippines was the leading country of origin for these workers, accounting for 12 percent of the total. Mexico followed at 11 percent, and India at 7 percent. The number of noncitizen immigrant workers in healthcare increased from about 961,000 in January 2025 to 1.2 million in April 2026. This trend occurred even as the overall United States noncitizen workforce declined during the same period.About 500,000 immigrant registered nurses were working in the United States in 2022, according to an analysis by KFF. This group accounted for roughly one in six of the nearly 3.2 million registered nurses in the country. The proportion of hospitals reporting that they hired foreign-educated registered nurses doubled from 16 percent in 2010 to 32 percent in 2022. An average of roughly 23,835 Schedule A petitions were filed annually between fiscal 2023 and 2025, indicating the volume of cases that would now be subject to the more rigorous PERM labor market test.Federal projections indicate that nursing shortages are expected to be much worse in rural areas compared to urban centers. The Health Resources and Services Administration projects an 8 percent nationwide shortage of registered nurses in 2028. This figure rises to 24 percent in nonmetropolitan areas, compared with only 5 percent in metropolitan areas. These geographic disparities highlight the critical role that international recruitment plays in sustaining healthcare delivery outside of major urban hubs. By 2038, the projected shortage falls to 11 percent in nonmetropolitan areas and 2 percent in metropolitan areas, according to federal forecasts.Jennifer Mensik Kennedy, president of the American Nurses Association, told Newsweek that international recruitment was useful but should not substitute for addressing domestic workforce problems. She stated that the United States cannot recruit its way out of the nursing workforce crisis. Retention, working conditions, administrative burden, staffing, and scheduling all must be addressed together. Kennedy warned that any policy that makes it harder to recruit and retain qualified nurses could intensify existing workforce pressures.The association is urging the administration to retain nurses on Schedule A. Kennedy said that immigration changes could affect both sides of hospitals' recruitment decisions. Nurses want to know whether working in the United States provides a stable path to remaining in the country. Employers need predictable timelines when planning staffing. Delays in the arrival of qualified nurses ultimately affect patients, she said.The potential delays come as employers already face lengthy labor certification processing times. According to the Department of Labor, the average PERM analyst review time over the 90 days ending October 31, 2026, was 315 calendar days. Eliminating Schedule A could add another layer of recruitment and administrative requirements for hospitals seeking to sponsor foreign nurses. The United States also faces obstacles to training more nurses at home. Nursing schools turned away 93,176 qualified applications in 2025, according to the American Association of Colleges of Nursing.For internationally educated nurses themselves, a longer or less predictable United States immigration process could influence which country they choose. Babate said that nurses considering migration balance professional opportunities against questions affecting their families. If the United States timeline becomes harder to plan around, some may look more closely at Canada or Australia, where registered nurses are included in skilled migration pathways. It is too early to know how many would change their plans.Dr. Jasper Erwin Tolarba, founder and immediate past president of the Society of Internationally Educated Nurses and Nursing Allies, similarly said that the United States competes internationally for healthcare workers. If the pathway to permanent residency in the United States becomes more difficult or unpredictable, he warned that we may see more nurses exploring opportunities in other countries. Tolarba cautioned, however, that international recruitment cannot by itself solve America's nursing workforce problems.Schedule A has survived for decades as a route for hospitals to sponsor foreign nurses without the standard PERM recruitment process. Whether it survives this proposed overhaul now rests with the Trump administration. The Labor Department must publish a final rule before the changes can take effect, but healthcare leaders warn that the delay in hiring foreign nurses will strain an already fragile system. Public comments are open until January 19, 2027. The proposal was published on November 17, and nothing has changed yet, but the impending rule could disrupt the current balance of staffing availability during the transition period.
Original source:
Head Topics
Comments 0