Montse Alvarado, the 39‑year‑old Mexican‑American president of EWTN News, has been appointed to lead the Vatican’s communications department.. The decision, announced in early June, places her in charge of the Holy See press office, Vatican News, Vatican Publishing and other media arms. it arrives at a time of strained ties between the U.S. Catholic network and Pope Francis’ curia.

Alvarado’s New Portfolio Includes the Holy See Press Office and Vatican News

According to the EWTN report, Alvarado will oversee the entire media network of the Holy See, encompassing the press office, Vatican News, the Vatican Publishing Residence and several other entities. This consolidation gives her unprecedented control over the Vatican’s public narrative,from daily bulletins to major papal announcements.

Why the Appointment Is Seen as an Olive Branch to American Conservatives

The move is interpreted by some observers as a signal that the Vatican is courting the U.S. right‑wing,especially after Pope Francis’ public spat with former President Donald Trump. As the source notes, the decision “is seen as an olive branch to American conservatives following the pope’s dust‑up with President Trump.”

Historical Friction: EWTN Critics of Francis and Vatican’s Communication Failures

Relations between EWTN and the Vatican have been rocky under Francis, with prominent hosts like Raymond Arroyo openly criticizing the pope’s theological direction. the source highlights that Francis once accused the network of “continually speaking ill of the pope.” Moreover, the Vatican’s communications office has been described as a “case study in institutional arrogance and incompetence,” particularly in handling sxeual‑abuse scandals.

Open Question: Will Alvarado Shift Vatican Messaging Toward Clearer Moral Guidelines?

The appointment raises the specific question of whether Alvarado will steer the Vatican toward “clearer and firmer moral guidelines” than those associated with Francis, as some analysts suggest.. The source does not provide evidence of her intended editorial line, leaving this as a key uncertainty.

What Remains Unverified: Alvarado’s Strategic Plan and Vatican’s Internal Support

Two critical points remain unclear: the concrete communication strategy Alvarado will implement, and the level of backing she has from senior Vatican officials. The source offers no details on a formal plan or on how curial leaders have responded to her appointment.