A cherished local institution in Greencastle, Mrs. Gibbles Candies and Restaurant, is preparing to cease operations. This closure marks the end of an era, as the beloved candy shop and eatery has served the community for almost fifty years.

End of an Era for a Community Staple

The decision to shut down comes following a profound personal loss for the owners. Close friends confirmed that owner Rodney Eshleman recently lost his wife and business partner, Kimberly, after she succumbed to cancer.

Former employee Ethan Izer shared that Kimberly battled cancer until her final days. For many in the town of just over 4,000 residents, the shop was more than just a business; it was interwoven with daily life.

Generational Ties to Mrs. Gibbles

The impact of Mrs. Gibbles is evident through the deep, multi-generational connections locals maintain with the establishment. Many residents have either worked there or have family members who were employed by the owners.

Family friend Kaitlyn Miller highlighted these deep roots. "My mom worked there 15 years, my grandma 16, and my husband has been making their caramel popcorn for 19 years," Miller stated.

More Than Just a Restaurant

Mrs. Gibbles was renowned for its comforting homemade food, particularly its iconic corn fritters. It functioned as a vital gathering spot for various groups within the community, including families and churchgoers.

Associate Pastor Casey Hurst noted the void the closure will create, saying, "It’s dinner after church. It’s going to feel like something is definitely missing." Miller added that it seemed like it was time for the owners to move forward.

Historical Significance of the Location

The building housing the restaurant possesses significant historical value in Greencastle. Before it became Mrs. Gibbles, the location operated as the Dixie Motor Inn.

This former iteration served as a comprehensive stop offering both food and gasoline, predating the construction of Interstate 83. For those who remember its past, the nostalgia remains strong, as Izer expressed, "There’s something really nostalgic about it."

The final day of service for Mrs. Gibbles Candies and Restaurant is scheduled for the end of April.