The Future of the Browns' Quarterback Position

At the recent annual NFL meetings, Cleveland Browns General Manager Andrew Berry confirmed the organization is open to a competition between Deshaun Watson and Shedeur Sanders. This sentiment was echoed by owner Jimmy Haslam, who suggested that if named the starter, Watson could still prove to be a successful investment for the franchise.

A History of Struggles and Injuries

Since his arrival in Cleveland in 2022, Watson has struggled to replicate his earlier career success. His tenure has been defined by inconsistency and significant health setbacks:

  • 2021: Sat out the entire season voluntarily.
  • 2022: Served an 11-game suspension.
  • 2023: Suffered a season-ending shoulder injury.
  • 2024: Ruptured his Achilles tendon twice.
  • 2025: Remained sidelined for the entire year to rehabilitate his Achilles.

Having only completed 19 games for the team, there is skepticism regarding whether the 30-year-old quarterback can endure the physical demands of a 17-game season.

Financial and Strategic Considerations

The Browns have restructured Watson’s contract four times since 2022. Following the 2026 season, the team has a clear path to release him using a post-June 1st designation, which would allow them to move on from the contract. Continuing to start him simply to justify past financial decisions may hinder the team's long-term progress.

Furthermore, the team faces a challenging schedule, including two matchups each against the Baltimore Ravens and the Pittsburgh Steelers. Given Watson's injury history, placing him behind center against elite pass rushes like those led by Trey Hendrickson and T.J. Watt presents a significant risk.

Prioritizing the Future

While some hope that head coach Todd Monken can revitalize Watson’s performance, the reality of his recent decline remains. Many argue that the team should prioritize the development of younger players like Shedeur Sanders, who showed potential during his seven starts in Cleveland.

With a defense capable of contending for a Super Bowl—and a commitment to keeping Myles Garrett—the Browns are positioned to build a competitive roster. By focusing on offensive line improvements and grooming a long-term quarterback for 2027, the organization could move past the controversies of the past and align better with the expectations of their fanbase.