On September 13, 2026, the Cleveland Browns suffered a 34-10 loss to the Jacksonville Jaguars at EverBank Stadium. Quarterback Deshaun Watson struggled in his first game since returning from a torn Achilles injury, leading to intense scrutiny of the team's offensive direction.

Advertisement

The 34-10 blowout at EverBank Stadium

The Jacksonville Jaguars dominated the contest from the opening whistle, establishing a commanding 24-0 lead by halftime. According to the report, Deshaun Watson’s statistical output of 16 completions on 22 attempts for 205 yards masked a much more difficult afternoon for the Cleveland offense. while Watson did record one touchdown and 38 rushing yards, a significant portion of his production—46 yards—occurred during "garbage time" late in the fourth quarteer.

The Browns' only touchdown came via a pass to Denzel Boston with less than two minutes remaining, a play that occurred well after the Jaguars had surged to a 31-0 advantage. Watson also faced significant pressure behind the line , enduring five sacks throughout the game. This performance marks a difficult chapter in a career that has seen Watson struggle to find consistency since his 2020 Pro Bowl season.

The $230 million contract and the shadow of the 2022 trade

Deshaun Watson continues to play under the immense pressurre of the largest guaranteed contract in NFL history,valued at $230 million. The Cleveland Browns' decision to trade for the former Texans star in 2022 remains a polarizing move, especially as Watson struggles to find rhythm. This recent outing in Jacksonville serves as a stark reminder of the high stakes involved in the Browns' long-term rebuilding strategy.

The optics of the situation are complicated by Watson's recent injury history, specifically his recovery from a torn Achilles suffered in 2024. As the team looks toward future matchups against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and the Carolina Panthers, the financial commitment to Watson remains the central tension within the Cleveland organization.

Todd Monken's defense of operational failures

Browns head coach Todd Monken has publicly pushed back against the narrative that Watson is solely responsible for the team's offensive struggles. During post-game comments, Monken argued that it is "unfair" to place the entirety of the blame on the quarterback, citing various operational issues within the team. The coach noted that the Browns struggled with getting in and out of the huddle and managing substitutions effectively.

Monken emphasized that his decision-making is focused on what is best for the Cleveland Browns moving forward,rather than reacting to external frustrations.. Despite the lopsided loss, the coach maintained that Watson did not appear to be playing tentatively, noting that the quarterback showed flashes of ability once the Jaguars had already secured an insurmountable lead.

Will Shedeur Sanders or Taylen Green start in Tampa Bay?

The Browns' quarterback room remains a source of significant uncertainty heading into Week 2. While Watson beat out Shedeur Sanders for the starting role during training camp, the coaching staff has not yet committed to a starter for the upcoming game against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Monken stated he needs time to evaluate the game tape before making a definitive decision.

Several specific questions remain unanswered following the Jaguars game:

  • Will the Browns pivot to Shedeur Sanders to provide a spark to the offense?
  • How will rookie Taylen Green or second-year player Dillon Gabriel fit into the rotation if the coaching staff seeks more mobility?
  • Is the current offensive scheme capable of protecting Watson from the high sack rate seen in Jacksonville?

    • The report suggests that the era of Deshaun Watson in Cleveland may be nearing its end, regardless of whether he starts next week.