Liberal MP Shaun Chen is facing online accusations that he participated in House of Commons votes while traveling in China earlier this year. These claims,fueled by social media videos and Conservative politicians, suggest a violation of parliamentary rules regarding remote voting.
The Hakka Canadian Association trip during the March 14–22 window
Liberal MP Shaun Chen traveled to China from March 14 to March 22 on a trip sponsored by the Hakka Canadian Association. This organization, which aims to promote friendships among Canada's Hakka community, is chaired by Markham Councillor Joe Li. As reported by the source, this was Chen's first and only trip to China since May 2019, undertaken on official parliamentary business alongside other MPs and senators.
During this period, House of Commons IT staff flagged the use of a loaned tablet and a phone with a temporary SIM card as a potentially high cybersecurity risk. this technical concern, noted in emails between Chen's office and IT staff, adds a layer of complexity to the trip, which was intended to be a diplomatic engagement rather than a legislative session.
The facial recognition and Standing Order 45 safeguards
House of Commons rules , specifically Standing Order 45 (12) (a), prohibit Members of Parliament from casting electronic votes while outside of Canada. To prevent such violations, the House uses an app that requires facial recognition technology to visually confirm a member's identity and presence. A spokesperson for House Speaker Francis Scarpaleggia noted that both technical controls and human validation processes are in place to ensure MPs are within Canadian borders when they vote.
Passport stamps and the March 22 Taipei-to-Toronto flight
Evidence provided by Shaun Chen’s office suggests he was back in Canada well before the controversial March 25 vote on the government's hate crime legislation, Bill C-9 . According to the report, Chen's passport contains visa stamps showing his departure from China occurred on March 22. furthermore, his office shared a boarding pass for a flight from Taipei to Toronto that departed at 6:50 p.m. local time on March 22,a journey that typically lands on the same day due to time zone changes.
The discrepancy between WeChat videos and the March 25 vote claim
Despite the documentation, critics including Conservative MP John Barlow and social media influencers have raised questions based on date-stamped videos shared on WeChat. These videos appear to show Chen in China during the period when allegations suggest he may have voted on legislation. While some observers, such as Lee, suggested the WeChat videos might have been edited or posted after the fact, the timing remains a point of contention for those questioning the MP's adherence to parliamentary procedure.
A significant unanswered question involves the perceived contradiction between Chen's health status and his travel capabilities. while Chen cited a vehicle accident last fall as the reason for his resignation and inability to travel to Ottawa frequently, critics have questioned why he was healthy enough for a trip to China but not for regular parliamentary duties in the capital. The office of Canada's conflict of interest and ethics commissioner has since released a public disclosure regarding the trip, but the debate over the MP's motivations continues.
Comments 0