Three years after a Land Rover crashed into a school in Wimbledon, resulting in the deaths of two eight-year-old girls, a new investigation is underway into the police’s handling of the case. The inquiry follows allegations of bias and a flawed initial investigation.

The Incident and Initial Response

On July 6th, Claire Freemantle lost control of her Land Rover Defender on a narrow road near Wimbledon Common. The vehicle crashed through a school fence, striking a Year Three picnic. Emergency services responded with 15 ambulances and 35 police cars, treating 16 people and hospitalizing a dozen.

Eight-year-old Selena Lau died at the scene, and Nuria Sajjad succumbed to her injuries three days later. Witnesses described the scene as filled with “a bang, scraping metal and screams.”

Re-examination of the Case

The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) initially declined to press criminal charges against Ms. Freemantle in 2024. However, the CPS is now re-evaluating this decision following a new dossier from detectives who re-investigated concerns about the original inquiry.

A verdict from the CPS is expected by the end of the month, based on a legal opinion submitted in April. Two previous investigations have been completed, and an inquest was opened but quickly adjourned.

IOPC Investigation and Allegations of Bias

The Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) is investigating the actions of 11 Met Police officers involved in the original investigation. This probe will assess the inquiry’s competency and the accuracy of information provided to the families.

Focus on Potential Bias

The IOPC investigation will specifically examine whether officers displayed “unconscious bias” towards the victims’ families, who are of Asian heritage. It will also assess whether Ms. Freemantle received preferential treatment due to her wealth and social standing.

Nuria Sajjad’s mother, Smera Chohan, has publicly criticized the Met Police for a lack of a “competent and thorough investigation,” demanding answers and expressing her distress.

Unanswered Questions

The central question remains how Ms. Freemantle lost control of her SUV on a quiet 20mph street. The location is not known for speeding or hazardous conditions, suggesting a significant lapse in driver control.

Ms. Freemantle has tested negative for alcohol and drugs. The case continues to unfold, raising serious questions about the investigation and the pursuit of justice for the victims and their families.