North Coast Repertory Theatre is currently presenting a lively production of James Sherman’s 1989 comedy, “Beau Jest.” The play humorously examines the anxieties surrounding interfaith relationships and the pressures of family expectations.

A Complicated Charade

The story revolves around Sarah, who has been secretly dating Chris, a non-Jewish man, for a year. To appease her religiously observant parents, she leads them to believe she is involved with a Jewish doctor named David. As Passover approaches, and her family anticipates meeting her boyfriend, Sarah finds herself in a panic.

An Actor to the Rescue

Instead of revealing the truth, Sarah hires an actor, Bob, to convincingly portray “Dr. David” during the family’s Seder. Ironically, Bob isn’t Jewish himself, but his experience touring with “Fiddler on the Roof” makes him surprisingly adept at the role and maintaining the deception.

Overcoming Playwright Challenges

While James Sherman’s play has some flaws – including a potentially grating protagonist and a lengthy Seder scene – director Omri Schein’s skillful direction maintains a brisk pace and consistent comedic timing. The six-member cast delivers a remarkably unified and improvisational performance.

Standout Performances

Sam Ashdown shines as Bob, the charming and likable actor. Josh Cahn, as Sarah’s therapist brother Joel, provides hilarious reactions and serves as the audience’s voice of reason. Katrina Michaels portrays Sarah with commendable honesty, showcasing both her vulnerabilities and eventual growth.

Joel Polis and Jill Remez deliver endearing performances as Sarah’s traditional parents, and Benjamin Cole is perfectly cast as the affable Chris. The production also benefits from strong design elements, including Marty Burnett’s set, Jennifer Brawn Gittings’ costumes, Evan Eason’s sound design, and Matthew Novotny’s lighting.

Themes of Family and Faith

“Beau Jest” explores themes of family, faith, and identity. While the premise may feel dated in today’s society, the underlying anxieties about family expectations and the desire for acceptance remain universally relatable. The play suggests that faith can be a unifying force.

The North Coast Rep’s production successfully highlights these themes, offering an entertaining and thought-provoking evening of theatre. Performances run through May 24th at 7 p.m. on Wednesdays and Thursdays, 8 p.m. on Fridays, 2 and 8 p.m. on Saturdays, and 2 and 7 p.m. on Sundays.