Actor Andrew Scott is generating significant Academy Award momentum following the Telluride Film Festival premiere of Elsinore. The biopic, which depicts Ian Charleson's final days, has alreday secured a 90% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.

Advertisement

The long road from Sherlock's Moriarty to the Academy Awards

Andrew Scott has spent years buildiing a reputation for intensity, moving from his BAFTA-winning turn as Moriarty in Sherlock to more nuanced roles. While his performance in All of Us Strangers earned him Golden Globe and BAFTA nods, he famously missed out on an Academy Award nomination.. This latest project, Elsinore, appears to be the vehicle that might finally break that streak.

Ian Charleson's final Hamlet preparations in Elsinore

Directed by Simon Stone and written by Stephen Beresford, Elsinore focuses on the final months of actor Ian Charleson as he prepares for a production of Hamlet while living with AIDS. The film, which features Olivia Colman as Dr. Margaret Johnson, has debuted to a 90% score on Rotten Tomatoes following its premiere at the 53rd Telluride Film Festival. The report indicates that Scott also serves as a producer on the 104-minute drama,which features a supporting cast including Billie Piper and Sadie Soverall.

Battling Pattinson and Damon for the Best Actor trophy

The race for the Best Actor category in 2027 is shaping up to be a crowded field. According to the report, Scott will likely face stiff competition from Robert Pattinson in Primetime, Matt Damon in The Odyssey, and Tom Cruise in Digger. With Academy Award nominations scheduled for announcement on January 21, 2027, the industry is watching closely to see if Scott can secure his first nomination before the ceremony on March 14, 2027.

Can a "formulaic" script hold back Scott's performance?

Despite the critical acclaim for Scott's "performance of a lifetime," some reviewers have raised concerns about the film's narrative structure. The source mentions that while the acting is top-tier, the execution of the story has been described by some as too formulaic. This leaves an open question for voters: will the Academy prioritize a transcendent individual performance, or will the perceived weaknesses in the script prevent Elsinore from reaching the top tier of nominees?