A psychiatrist who previously warned Valdo Calocane would ‘end up killing someone’ has revised his claim, stating he only said it to ‘shock’ the killer, not because he genuinely believed it would happen.

Nottingham Attack Investigation

The inquiry is investigating the circumstances surrounding the deaths of three people in Nottingham in June 2023. Valdo Calocane fatally stabbed students Barney Webber and Grace O’Malley-Kumar, along with school caretaker Ian Coates, during a violent rampage.

Initial Warning and Subsequent Revision

Dr. Faizal Seedat initially expressed serious concerns about Calocane’s mental state and potential for violence in 2020, following an incident where a woman suffered a broken back attempting to escape him. However, during testimony, Dr. Seedat explained his earlier warning was a deliberate attempt to ‘shock’ Calocane into recognizing the severity of his behavior.

He clarified he didn’t believe Calocane would commit murder, but feared a repetition of violent actions could cause further harm.

Concerns Over Discharge and Risk Assessment

Evidence presented to the inquiry revealed Dr. Seedat’s 2020 warning was followed by Calocane’s discharge from care just two weeks later. This has raised questions about the risk assessment process and the adequacy of support provided.

Dr. Seedat explained his statement was a calculated effort to emphasize the gravity of Calocane’s situation and the potential for escalating consequences.

'Red Rum' Reference and Plea to Manslaughter

Testimony revealed Dr. Seedat was aware of concerning text messages sent by Calocane in 2020, referencing ‘red rum’ – understood as ‘murder’ spelled backwards – and a desire to inflict harm. He admitted he initially misinterpreted the phrase as a religious reference.

Calocane pleaded guilty to manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility and received a hospital order. This outcome has been met with criticism from the victims’ families, who were disappointed a murder trial was not pursued.

Therapeutic Approach and Ongoing Inquiry

Dr. Seedat’s testimony focused on his therapeutic approach, aiming to create a sense of urgency and responsibility in Calocane by presenting a worst-case scenario. He maintained his intention was not to predict a murder, but to emphasize the potential for escalating harm. The inquiry is ongoing, with further evidence expected to illuminate the factors contributing to the tragic case.