Split Verdict Reached in Diller Shooting Case

A New York City jury has delivered a split verdict in the trial of Guy Rivera, the man accused of killing NYPD Detective Jonathan Diller during a traffic stop in Queens in 2024. Jurors found Rivera not guilty of murder, but guilty of lesser charges related to the fatal shooting.

Details of the Conviction

The jury determined that Rivera was guilty of aggravated manslaughter in the first degree, attempted murder in the first degree, and criminal possession of a weapon. These convictions stem from the shooting of 31-year-old Detective Jonathan Diller in Far Rockaway earlier this year.

Jury Deliberations and Initial Disagreement

The initial verdict revealed a disagreement among jurors, with one juror initially dissenting. The judge reminded the jury of the requirement for a unanimous decision, and they were sent back to continue deliberations. After several hours, the jury reaffirmed the same split verdict.

Timeline and Background of the Shooting

The Incident on March 25, 2024

Prosecutors stated that on March 25, 2024, Detective Diller responded to reports of violence and robbery concerns at the Mott Avenue train station in Far Rockaway, even while off-duty. He was with members of the NYPD’s Community Response team when Rivera was observed with a gun in his pocket.

The Confrontation and Shooting

According to prosecutors, Rivera entered a car with another man, Lindy Jones, and disregarded police commands. After being pulled from the vehicle, Rivera allegedly shot Detective Diller. Diller was struck in the torso, below his bullet-resistant vest, and later died from his injuries at the hospital.

Allegations and Evidence

Prosecutors also alleged that Rivera pointed the weapon at Sergeant Sasha Rosen after shooting Diller, but the gun malfunctioned. Rivera was himself shot twice by police during the encounter. The trial included bodycam footage of the incident and testimony from Detective Diller’s widow.

Defense Arguments

Rivera’s defense team argued that the shooting was an 'unintentional discharge' of his firearm. They claimed that Sergeant Rosen grabbed Rivera’s wrist, causing the gun to fire, an allegation Rosen denied in court. Rivera had previously pleaded not guilty to charges of first-degree murder of a police officer, attempted murder, and criminal possession of a weapon.

Aftermath and Sentencing

Sentencing for Guy Rivera is scheduled for April 27, at which time victim impact statements will be presented. The loss of Detective Diller has been deeply felt within the NYPD community. Dozens of officers attended court hearings throughout the trial to show their support.

Remembering Detective Diller

Detective Diller, a husband and father from Long Island, was posthumously promoted to detective. His funeral in Massapequa was attended by hundreds of police officers, including a visit from President Trump who spoke with Diller’s wife.