Seattle Homicide Suspect Apprehended

Isaiah Andrews, a suspect in a Seattle homicide case, has been arrested by U.S. Marshals after being mistakenly released from a California jail several months ago. The arrest took place on April 1st, bringing an end to a months-long search.

Details of the Original Crime

The Murder of Theodore Wheeler

The case stems from the October 15, 2025, murder of Theodore Wheeler in North Seattle. Wheeler was found with a gunshot wound to the chest in a hotel parking lot and died shortly after emergency crews arrived.

Arrest and Initial Detention

Following the shooting, Isaiah Andrews, 20, was identified as the suspect and traced to Antioch, California. He was arrested on October 18, 2025, by the Contra Costa County Sheriff’s Office after a car chase involving multiple law enforcement agencies.

Mistaken Release from California Jail

Andrews was initially booked into the Contra Costa County Jail on a temporary felony warrant for homicide related to the Seattle shooting. However, he was subsequently released in error. Authorities have not detailed the circumstances surrounding the mistaken release.

U.S. Marshals' Pursuit and Arrest

After learning of Andrews’ incorrect release, U.S. Marshals launched an investigation and pursued him for several months. Their efforts culminated in his arrest on April 1st, bringing him back into custody to face charges in connection with Wheeler’s death.