Blind Test: Finding the Best Headphones

WIRED recently put five premium headphone brands to the test using an unconventional method: a blind test with three strangers. The participants were tasked with evaluating audio quality, comfort, and noise-canceling capabilities without any knowledge of the brands or prices involved.

The Contenders

The headphones included in the test were the Apple AirPods Max, Anker Soundcore Space One Pro, Sony WH-1000XM6, Sonos Ace, and Nothing Headphones. Testers were asked to provide their honest opinions on each pair.

Initial Impressions & Comfort

First Reactions

Initial reactions varied. One tester described a pair as having a design that “just screams, boot up the old desktop computer.” Another noted that a particular set “feel[s] good” and is “very comfortable” for daily wear. Some found certain models “too flimsy,” while others appreciated the design.

Comfort Levels

Comfort was a key factor in the evaluation. Testers commented on the level of cushioning and how the headphones felt during extended use. One participant stated, “who doesn’t like a little cushion, you know?” Another found a specific pair “not as comfortable.”

Audio Quality & Lossless Performance

Sound Evaluation

Testers assessed the audio quality of each headphone, noting differences in bass, high-range clarity, and overall soundstage. One tester observed that the audio on a particular set came “cleaner” when using lossless audio. Another felt the bass was “a little weak” on one model.

The Impact of Lossless Audio

The test highlighted the significant difference between standard and lossless audio. Participants noted that lossless audio brought back the high range and created a more immersive listening experience, with one tester saying, “You felt like you were there.”

Price Guesses & Final Verdict

Price Predictions

After evaluating all five headphones, the testers were asked to guess the price of the Apple AirPods Max. One participant surprisingly believed they were the cheapest option. The Sony WH-1000XM6 were identified as being around $458.

Overall Rankings

The Sony XM6 series were recognized for their suitability for travel. The Sonos Ace were considered a more budget-friendly option. The Nothing Headphones were praised for their unique styling. Ultimately, audio quality was the deciding factor for many testers.