Family Files Lawsuit Against San Bernardino County Sheriff

An Apple Valley family has filed a federal lawsuit against the San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department following an incident where a deputy shot one of their family members. The shooting occurred after the family called 911 to report a potential burglary at their home.

The Incident: February 24, 2025

On February 24, 2025, Tamara Brown called 911 after mistaking her husband for an intruder. Security camera footage shows Deputy Jose Guzman arriving at the family’s residence in Apple Valley. The deputy initially knocked on the door and then positioned himself behind a pillar.

911 Dispatcher's Guidance

According to the family’s attorney, DEnisse Gastélum, the 911 dispatcher advised Ms. Brown that it was safe to exit the home. Ms. Brown informed the dispatcher that there were five family members, including two young children. The dispatcher reportedly assured her it was safe to walk outside.

Shooting and Injuries

Surveillance video depicts the family exiting the house, with 18-year-old Elijah Brown trailing slightly behind his siblings while holding a knife. Deputy Guzman then fired his weapon, striking Elijah Brown three times in the chest and stomach.

Family's Account

“My son wasn’t even out the door yet, and he starts shooting. He didn’t know who he was,” Tamara Brown stated. Elijah Brown survived the shooting and was present at a press conference with his family. “He could’ve been dead,” Ms. Brown added, “He was almost dead.”

Lawsuit Details and Claims

The family’s lawsuit asserts that Elijah Brown was carrying the knife for protection and was moving towards safety, not towards Deputy Guzman. They are seeking monetary damages, disciplinary action against the deputy, and enhanced departmental training. “If somebody called him out, that’s what they should come out to make sure that we’re safe,” Tamara Brown said. “That’s what they should have, but they didn’t do that.”

Sheriff's Department Response

The San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department maintains that the deputy’s actions were lawful and in line with department policy and training. In a statement, the department described the information presented by the family and their attorney as “inaccurate” and not reflective of the complete circumstances known to the deputy at the time.

Investigation Status

The department completed its investigation in February 2026 and submitted the case to the District Attorney’s Office for review. Prosecutors have confirmed they are currently reviewing the case. Due to pending litigation, the department stated it is limited in what it can publicly discuss.