Finding the Perfect Easter Basket Fillers

With spring approaching, creating Easter baskets is a beloved tradition. Finding a delightful mix of surprises and practical gifts without overspending can be a challenge. This guide compiles 70 excellent Easter basket filler ideas for toddlers, elementary-schoolers, tweens, and teens, all recommended by Strategist parents and priced under $40.

Timing is Key for Easter Delivery

To ensure timely delivery, it’s best to make your selections as soon as possible. Many items can still arrive by Sunday, April 5th, depending on your location. Waiting longer may require relying on local store pickup.

Tips for Building a Great Easter Basket

Approaches to Easter baskets vary, but a helpful strategy is to include items you were already planning to purchase, like new swimsuits for spring and summer. For older children, consider adding a special treat or two. Keeping the basket itself small or using a giftable container can also create a more abundant look.

Easter Basket Ideas by Age & Interest

For Babies & Toddlers

  • Color-Matching Eggs: These shape-sorting eggs provide engaging play for little ones, offering hours of entertainment.
  • Wooden Carrot Patch: A puzzle that helps develop problem-solving skills as children match different sized carrots to their spots.
  • Color-Changing Bath Tablets: Add vibrant color and a fun learning experience to bath time.
  • Green Toys Wagon: Made from recycled materials, this wagon is perfect for hauling Easter loot.
  • Wooden Blocks: Classic wooden blocks encourage creativity and building skills.
  • Pouch Puzzles: These 12-piece puzzles zip into a portable bag for on-the-go fun.
  • DUPLO Sets: Larger LEGOs designed for toddlers, promoting safe and engaging building.
  • Haba Shakers: A set of five wooden shakers, each producing a unique sound.

For Elementary Schoolers

  • “Love You to the Moon and Back” Book: A heartwarming classic about the bond between parent and child.
  • Pip Squeak Markers: Half-size Crayola markers ideal for developing fine motor skills.
  • Babiators Sunglasses: Stylish sunglasses with a replacement guarantee.
  • Silent Basketball: A quiet basketball perfect for apartment living.
  • Classic Pail: A durable pail for backyard fun and sand play.
  • Dump Truck: A favorite toy for one-year-olds, perfect for carrying small treasures.

For Tweens & Teens

  • Magna-Tiles: Versatile magnetic tiles offering endless building possibilities.
  • Swim Goggles: Easy-to-adjust goggles for the water-loving kid.
  • Brush & Emoji Markers: Nifty markers with brush tips and emoji stamps.
  • Slime Kits: Kits for creating colorful and textured slime.
  • UNO Card Game: A fast-paced and engaging card game for the whole family.
  • Beaded Jump Ropes: Easy-to-carry jump ropes for practicing skills.
  • Brain-Teaser Puzzles: Challenging puzzles that promote critical thinking.
  • Beyblade Tops: Spinning tops with rip cords for exciting battles.
  • Squishmallows: Popular plush toys in a variety of styles.
  • Posca Paint Markers: Vibrant markers for artistic expression.
  • Shashibo Magnetic Cubes: Fidget cubes that transform into prismatic shapes.
  • Swedish Fish Gummies: A sweet treat for older kids and teens.
  • Phone Mount: A silicone suction mount for hands-free phone use.