The Philadelphia Eagles have made 53 first-round picks in the Super Bowl era (since 1966). Some players have dramatically altered the franchise’s trajectory for the better, while others failed to live up to expectations.

The High Stakes of First-Round Picks

In three weeks, the Eagles will – barring a trade – make another first-round draft pick. These selections are intensely scrutinized, representing a team’s investment in future success. The NFL has elevated the first round into a major event, and for good reason.

Notable Busts and Missed Opportunities

Early Disappointments

Allen fizzled out quickly, seeing a diminished role in his rookie season. He later tested positive for cocaine during training camp in 1986 and was subsequently released and faced legal charges.

Reagor, while not the worst pick on the list, stands out due to the availability of Justin Jefferson. The Eagles needed a receiver and ultimately chose incorrectly.

Underperforming Talent

Jones, an All-American from Arkansas, failed to translate his college success to the NFL. He amassed only 85 rushing yards on 44 attempts across 29 games, failing to score a touchdown.

Renfro lasted just two seasons in the NFL. Critically, defensive tackle Dana Stubblefield was available and selected two picks later, going on to win NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year and earn three Pro Bowl selections.

Reaching for Potential

The Eagles reached for Smith in the first round to improve their pass rush, passing over DeMarcus Lawrence. Smith recorded only four sacks in 37 games with the Eagles, finishing his career with 6.5 sacks in 57 games. Lawrence, meanwhile, has 67.5 career sacks.

Early Career Struggles

Reaves struggled as a starter in his rookie season, posting more interceptions than touchdowns. He spent three seasons with the Eagles before becoming a journeyman backup.

Defensive Line Misses

Harris made only eight starts in 24 games with the Eagles, recording just two sacks. The team could have selected Trevor Pryce three picks later, who went on to record 91 sacks in 14 NFL seasons.

Injuries and Unfulfilled Promise

Dillard showed promise as a reserve and was poised to start in 2020 before a season-ending injury. He was ultimately beaten out for a starting role, while Tytus Howard, drafted immediately after him, became a seven-year starter for Houston.

Substance Abuse Issues

Williams started all 16 games and earned all-rookie honors, but his career was derailed by multiple marijuana-related suspensions, ultimately ending his NFL career.

Unexpected Paths and Unfortunate Circumstances

Life After Football

Watkins, a 26-year-old firefighter, prioritized his passion for firefighting over his NFL career. He started 18 of 24 games before leaving the league to pursue his true calling.

Tragedy and Setbacks

McDougle’s career was hampered by injuries and a serious health issue. He was diagnosed with an irregular heartbeat and later shot during an armed robbery, missing significant playing time.

Mixed Results and Lasting Impacts

Solid Contributors

Mitchell had a key play in team history – the fourth-and-26 reception – but finished his Eagles career with modest statistics. Haddix was a capable blocker and receiver, but the Eagles passed on Hall of Famers Bruce Matthews, Dan Marino, and Darrell Green.

Early Picks with Limited Returns

Keyes played both running back and safety, but didn’t deliver the impact expected of a third overall pick. Harris recorded 7.5 sacks in three seasons with the Eagles, but the team passed on Hall of Fame running back John Riggins.

Decent Players, Better Alternatives

Jackson had two stints with the Eagles, but his career numbers didn’t justify his fourth overall draft position. Holmes was a serviceable player, but the Eagles missed out on Hall of Fame guard Will Shields.

Solid, But Not Spectacular

Zabel and Rossovich both had respectable NFL careers, but didn’t reach the level expected of their draft positions.

Recent Draft Picks and Lingering Questions

Barnett’s impact is debated, though he has a Super Bowl fumble recovery to his name. The Eagles could have drafted T.J. Watt 16 picks later. Mayberry was a nine-year Eagle, but the team passed on Ray Lewis. Bunkley was a solid run stuffer, but Mamula had 31.5 sacks, though the Eagles traded up to draft him and could have selected Warren Sapp. Agholor’s best season helped the Eagles win Super Bowl LII. Campbell is too early to evaluate. Smith showed promise before a torn ACL ended his career.