Delaware County Cases Under Review

Three convicted defendants are requesting their cases be re-examined following allegations of sexual assault against Delaware County Judge James Schuck. The requests raise concerns about potential misconduct and bias influencing trials and sentencing decisions.

Allegations Against Judge Schuck

In November, an assistant Delaware County prosecutor accused Judge Schuck of sexually assaulting her in his chambers last year. The prosecutor further alleged that Schuck subsequently engaged in a pattern of harassment, sending thousands of text messages and social media messages seeking a sexual relationship.

Defendants Challenging Convictions

Rhonda Coomes, a day care provider serving over 40 years for child abuse, argues in court documents that the allegations of misconduct and the appearance of bias impacted her case and sentencing. Jason Fuller, convicted of child abuse for forcing his children to live in a shed and consume dog food, also challenges his conviction, claiming the judge’s alleged pursuit of a sexual relationship with a prosecutor influenced his sentence.

Raymond Davis, convicted of gross sexual imposition, asserts that Judge Schuck was biased in favor of the prosecution. However, a judge has already denied Davis’ request for a new trial, citing the assistant prosecutor’s non-involvement in his trial and her absence from the office at the time.

Investigations and Responses

Delaware County Prosecutor Melissa Shiffel has announced an external review of cases presided over by Judge Schuck and involving the assistant prosecutor. Shiffel stated the review is nearing completion. Last week, Judge Schuck agreed to a protection order without a hearing.

Judge Schuck has admitted to an affair with the prosecutor and has voluntarily taken a leave of absence. The Montgomery County Sheriff is currently investigating whether any crimes were committed, but has not released any updates on the investigation.

Other News

  • Columbus Shooting: A man in his 30s is expected to survive after being accidentally shot by his juvenile son in South Linden.
  • Epstein Lawsuit: Women alleging they were victims of Jeffrey Epstein have filed a lawsuit against billionaire Les Wexner.