The 10.5-Year Consequences

A Maricopa County Superior Court judge handed down a 10.5-year prison sentence to Ian Mitcham for sexual assault and second-degree burglary in the 2015 murder of Allison Feldman in Scottsdale, Arizona.

According to the court, the consecutive sentences reflect the view that the crimes were distinct offenses.

Prosecutors now must decide whether to offer Mitcham a plea deal for life in prison or to retry the penalty phase with a new jury.

A Trauma that Persists

Allison's family described the horrific nature of the crimes and the enduring pain from her loss.

They highlighted the sexual assault and burglary as additional violations of her dignity and safety.

The family continues to grapple with the trauma of her murder.

Unresolved Murder Charge

The murder charge itself remains unresolved after a mistrial in the penalty phase.

The mistrial occurred after the jury deadlocked on whether to impose a life or death sentence.

A juror had shared information about prison life from her boyfriend,which led to her dismissal.

Mitcham's next court appearance is set for July 29.

FOX 10's Report

The information is based on a Maricopa County Superior Court sentencing hearing on May 28 , 2026, and a FOX 10 report from May 27 .