Edmonton Oilers forward Zach Hyman has publicly supported the team's decision to appoint Mike Babcock as head coach. Hyman highlighted his own successful tenure under Babcock in Toronto as evidence of the coach's value to the organization.

Advertisement

The 2019-20 Toronto resignation and privacy allegations

The appointment of Mike Babcock to the Edmonton Oilers is not without friction, primarily due to the circumstances surrounding his departure from the Toronto Maple Leafs. As the source report indicates,Babcock resigned from the Leafs midway through the 2019-20 season following allegations of "controversial antics" and an alleged intrusion into the privacy of his players.

This period marked a significant fracture in the relationship between the coach and his roster, leading to a hiatus from professional coaching that lasted until his 2023 hiring by the Edmonton Oilers. For many observers, the move represents a willingness by the Oilers to prioritize tactical expertise over the cultural baggage associated with Babcock's time in Toronto.

Zach Hyman's personal history with 'Babs'

Zach Hyman provides a crucial counter-narrative to the controversy, drawing on his years as a player under Babcock's leadership. Hyman , who played for the Toronto Maple Leafs before joining the Edmonton Oilers after the 2021 season, describes his experience as overwhelmingly positive, stating, "He was phenomenal to me as a young player."

According to the report, Hyman believes that Babcock's ability to teach is "incredible" and that the current Oilers group is excited to have a leader who can "command" the room. While Hyman admitted that players generally have little influence over coaching hires, he suggests that his own positive history with the coach informs his confidence in the decision.

The NHL and NHLPA clearance process

A central point of the Oilers' justification for the hire is the formal vetting process conducted by the league's governing bodies. Hyman emphasized that it was "really important" that both the NHL and the NHLPA completed the necessary investigations into Babcock's conduct before he was cleared to return to the bench.

The report says that the Edmonton Oilers conducted their own due diligence, speaking with other players and organizations across the league to gauge the current sentiment regarding Babcock. By leaning on the official clearance from the NHL and NHLPA, the Oilers are positioning the hire as a sanctioned return rather than a gamble on a disgraced figure.

Which former players still object to the Babcock hire?

Despite Hyman's vocal support, several critical gaps remain in the narrative. The source mentions a "checkered past" and "controversial anttics ," but it does not specify the exact nature of the privacy intrusions or name the specific players who clashed with Babcock during his Toronto tenure.

Furthermore, while the report highlights Hyman's comfort with the hire, it remains unclear if this sentiment is shared universally across the Edmonton Oilers locker room. The source provides the perspective of one supportive player, but it does not include statements from other teammates or former Babcock subordinates who may hold a different view of his coaching methods.