Republican attorney Etan Harris has secured a judgeship in the Brooklyn Municipal Court. He beat Democrat Susan Liebman in a closely contested race within the eighth judicial district.
Harris's 50.96% victory in the eighth judicial district
Etan Harris captured 38,915 votes to secure his seat on the Brooklyn Municipal Court, according to preliminary results from the city Board of Elections. This win in the eighth judicial district—which spans from Coney Island and Sheepshead Bay to Canarsie and Gravesend—saw Harris edge out Democrat Susan Liebman, who received 48.82% of the vote with 97.45% of scanners counted.
The result is being framed by GOP leaders as a historic shift, claiming such an upset in one of the borough's southern judicial districts has not occurred in decades. While the margin was slim,the victory for Etan Harris represents a break from the long-standing one-party dominance that has typically defined judicial elections in this region of Brooklyn.
The Syrian rabbi lineage and Orthodox Jewish outreach
The victory for Etan Harris was built on a "law and order" platform and strategic cultural appeals. As reported, Harris leveraged his background as the descendant of a Syrian chief rabbi and the grandson of a union judge who practiced in Israel to build trust with specific voting blocs. His campaign utilized Instagram to maintain high engagement with Chinese-American and Orthodox Jewish leaders in Southern Brooklyn.
Born and raised in Southern Brooklyn to a public school teacher and an architect, Etan Harris positioned his candidacy as a necessary alternative for voters. He argued that residents of the eighth judicial district previously lacked a genuine choice during general election cycles, a narrative that appeared to resonate across the district's diverse demographic makeup.
A contrast to the 40-point Democratic lead in the Fourth Municipal District
While Etan Harris achieved a rare GOP success, the broader New York City judicial landscape remains overwhelmingly Democratic.. In Brooklyn's Fourth Municipal District, for instance, Democratic candidates Anthony Vaughn Jr. and Xavier Carr defeated Republican Aaron Franklin by more than 40 points. This disparity suggests that Harris's win was a localized phenomenon rather than a borough-wide trend.
Similar trends appeared in Queens, where Democrat Janet Ellen Keller won her seat with a 50-point lead over Republican Stephen Dachtera, and Michelle Ann McSweeney-Ortiz won her race by over 45 points. In the Bronx , Democratic candidates Jodi L. morales and Sara Collins-Sedey cruised to victory in uncontested races, reinforcing the partisan divide between the eighth district and the rest of the city.
The paradox of Steven Chan and Lester Chang's endorsements
One of the more curious aspects of the Etan Harris campaign is the performance of his political backers.. Harris was endorsed by Republican state Senator Steven Chan and state Assemblyman Lester Chang, both of whom lost their own general election bids to Democrats. this creates a specific open question:why did the "law and order" messaging resonate for a judicial seat in the eighth judicial district while failing to save the legislative seats of the very men who supported Harris?
Furthermore, the source reports that most other municipal seats in Brooklyn were filled through uncontested elections or decisive Democratic wins. This leaves it unclear whether the Etan Harris model of targeted ethnic outreach is a scalable strategy for the GOP or if it only works for judicial roles where voters may be less focused on legislative party platforms.
The 11-point Democratic win on Staten Island
The results in other boroughs further highlight the isolation of the Etan Harris victory. On Staten Island, Democrat John Vitucci Jr. defeated Republican Carrie Ann Low for the First District Civil Court judgeship by 11 percentage points.. Low, a former Deputy Bureau Chief at the Staten Island District Attorney's Office, was unable to overcome the Democratic lead despite her law enforcement credentials.
Across Manhattan, the trend of Democratic stability continued, with candidates like Eric Flores, Steven Benathen, and Faith Bondy winning their respective municipal judge positions. only the Manhattan Seventh District showed a slight deviation from the norm, where Fair Court party candidate Aija Tingling joined three Democrats in securing seats.
Comments 0