The Republican primary runoff election for Place 3 on the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals is set for May 26th, pitting Alison Fox against Thomas Smith. Both candidates advanced from the initial primary held in March, with Fox receiving 31.3% of the vote and Smith securing 30.7%.

The Candidates

Alison Fox

Alison Fox is a seasoned attorney with significant experience before the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals. She previously served as a staff attorney within the writs of habeas corpus division of the court.

Fox emphasizes her dedication to defending the Constitution and upholding the rule of law. She also integrates her faith into her vision for a just legal system, believing that moral truths strengthen the legal framework.

Thomas Smith

Thomas Smith is a former prosecutor who has received strong political endorsements. He positions himself as a champion for public safety, particularly for women and children.

Smith highlights his work with the Texas Attorney General’s Office and state lawmakers on issues such as human trafficking and the state’s ban on sanctuary cities.

The Importance of the Election

The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals holds considerable power, reviewing death penalty cases – including the recent review of Clarence Curtis Jordan’s sentence after 47 years on death row – and handling appeals from lower courts. The court also addresses petitions challenging the legality of detention for those convicted of state felonies.

Given the historical dominance of Republicans in Texas, the winner of the GOP runoff is widely expected to win the general election.

Supporting Independent Journalism

The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit news organization, is actively seeking donations to continue its in-depth, truthful, and transparent reporting to Texans. The organization is committed to accuracy, completeness, and fairness, and provides a dedicated corrections page for any errors.

Readers are encouraged to report any inaccuracies they find directly to The Texas Tribune. This coverage is reported by Alex Nguyen and María Méndez.

Financial disclosures show Fox received a $4,000 donation from the Re-Elect David Newell for Judge Campaign in October, while Smith received support from a private criminal defense attorney in November.