Shadow Justice Secretary Nick Timothy has condemned the Ministry of Justice for spending nearly £2 million annually on a unit tracking racial disparities in prisons.. the Conservative MP argues these funds should instead be used to expand prison capacity amid a controversial early release program.
The £1.7 million cost of 20 disparities analysts
According to the report, the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) allocates approximately £1.7 million per year to a specialized "dispaities unit" tasked with monitoring diversity metrics across probation services and prisons. This unit is staffed by an average of 20 full-time equivalent employees who analyze racial and diversity data to identify systemic issues within the justice system.
The financial scale of this operation is further highlighted by current recruitment efforts. hM Prisons and Probation Service (HMPPS) is currently advertising for a disparities analyst with a salary reaching up to £53,081 per year. The role requires the successful candidate to produce quality-assured analysis to help senior leaders at HMPPS understand the drivers of disparity and determine where policy interventions are necessary.
A battle over the Public Sector Equality Duty and 50,000 new cells
The dispute over the disparities unit reflects a deeper ideological clash regarding the role of the civil service. Nick Timothy has characterized the spending as a promotion of "DEI ideology," arguing that taxpayers should not fund analysts who seek to label prisons as racist. this friction is part of a broader political movement to scrutinize Diversity, Equality, and Inclusion (DEI) spending across the UK public sector.
As a counter-proposal, the Conservative Party has pledged to repeal the Public Sector Equality Duty, which mandates that public bodies consider how their policies affect people with protected characteristics. instead, Nick Timothy claims the Conservatives would prioritize the construction of 50,000 additional prison places to ensure that serious and repeat offenders remain incarcerated rather than being released early.
The 33 per cent threshold and the surge in early releases
The controversy over the MoJ's spending arrives as the government implements a drastic early release scheme. As reported in the source, prisoners who previously served 40 to 50 per cent of their sentences are now being freed after serving only 33 per cent. This program, which began on October 1 with the release of 700 criminals , is expected to free up to 50,000 prisoners annually.
The impact of these changes extends to high-risk offenders. Criminals convicted of certain sexual or violent offenses, who were once eligible for relase at the two-thirds mark of their sentence, may now be released at the halfway stage. While a Prison Service spokesman noted that the disparities unit's budget represents less than 0.1 per cent of the overall HMPPS budget, the Conservatives warn that the early release program poses an "acute threat" to public safety.
Catherine McKinnell's missing budget comparisons
Significant gaps remain in the public record regarding the MoJ's financial management of these units. Prisons and Probation Minister Catherine McKinnell was unable to provide specific details on whether spending on the disparities unit has increased or decreased over time. She attributed this lack of data to changes in the unit's scope and structure, meaning comparable figures from previous years are unavailable.
Furthermore, the government has faced accusations of a cover-up regarding the exact number of criminals freed under the new early release program. While the MoJ has confirmed the expansion of the scheme to include those with sentences up to 29 months as of October 13, the total number of individuals released remains obscured, leaving the public and opposition lawmakers to question the true scale of the exodus from the prison estate.
Comments 0