Calvin Duncan, who spent nearly three decades wrongfully imprisoned before his exoneration, won an election in New Orleans. However, Louisiana Republicans, led by Governor Jeff Landry and the state Legislature, are now seeking to abolish his newly won position before he can take office on May 4th.

Duncan's Electoral Victory and Platform

In November 2025, Duncan secured 68% of the vote to become the Orleans Parish clerk of criminal court. His campaign focused on justice system reform, informed by his personal experience navigating court records while incarcerated. His election was seen as a significant moment, promising a fresh perspective on the clerk's role.

Legislative Action Against the Position

Republican-Led Bill to Abolish Office

On April 8th, Louisiana Senate Republicans voted to advance a bill that would eliminate Duncan's position. This move is part of a larger Republican effort to restructure New Orleans' judiciary. The state Legislature is heavily controlled by Republicans, who are also reportedly working to weaken the Voting Rights Act.

Controversy and Accusations

The legislative action has drawn significant controversy, with many questioning the motives. Duncan believes the move is retaliatory, citing past resistance from Louisiana officials regarding his innocence. He is listed on the National Registry of Exonerations, highlighting the injustice he faced.

Governor's Justification and Counterarguments

Claims of Efficiency and Addressing Corruption

Governor Jeff Landry stated that the elimination of the office is intended to improve 'government efficiency' and combat 'dysfunction and corruption' within the Orleans Parish system. He presented the action as a measure to reform the judiciary.

Political Polarization

Democrats have accused Republicans of a power grab aimed at undermining voter intent. The conflicting perspectives underscore the deep political divisions surrounding Duncan's situation.

Duncan's Journey and Advocacy

Wrongful Conviction and Refusal to Plead Guilty

Duncan was wrongly imprisoned for 28 years for a 1981 murder. In 2011, prosecutors offered a plea deal for time served, which he refused, maintaining his innocence. He was released from jail following the plea but continued to fight for exoneration.

Exoneration and Continued Activism

In 2021, a judge vacated his sentence, agreeing he was unjustly convicted. Duncan also played a role in a 2020 U.S. Supreme Court decision ending non-unanimous jury convictions. He founded a non-profit to help incarcerated individuals access the court system, a cause stemming directly from his own struggles.

Duncan views his election as the clerk of criminal court as the culmination of his lifelong fight against injustice.