California’s police accreditation body, the Commission on Police Officer Standards and Training (POST), is considering revoking the licenses of two Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) officers over a controversial 2021 shooting.

First-of-its-Kind Case

This decision would be the first time POST has considered decertifying officers for an on-duty shooting, potentially setting a precedent for police accountability within the state. Officers José Zavala and Julio Quintanilla are at the center of the case.

The Shooting of Margarito Lopez Jr.

The officers are accused of using excessive force when they fatally shot Margarito Lopez Jr., a 22-year-old man experiencing a mental health crisis and armed with a knife. The civilian advisory board for POST found clear evidence that the officers’ actions were unjustified, stating Lopez did not pose a threat to anyone but himself.

Recommendations and Potential Appeals

The advisory board recommended suspending or revoking the officers’ certifications, with a final decision expected from the full commission next month. If decertified, Zavala and Quintanilla would have the right to appeal to an administrative law judge.

Recent Reforms and Legal Protections

For years, California offered strong legal protections to police officers, often allowing those accused of misconduct to resign and seek employment elsewhere. Recent reforms have aimed to strengthen accountability measures within the state.

Details of the Incident

On December 18, 2021, Lopez’s sister called 911 after he threatened self-harm. Officers confronted Lopez outside his apartment in Historic South Central, where he held a 6-inch butcher knife to his throat.

After a ten-minute standoff, Lopez moved toward the officers, prompting Zavala and Quintanilla to open fire. He was later pronounced dead at a hospital.

Internal Investigation Findings

The LAPD’s internal investigation determined that the officers violated department policies, as Lopez did not present an immediate threat. Zavala received a ten-day suspension, while Quintanilla was suspended for five days. The case has also been referred to the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s office for potential criminal charges.

Reactions and Ongoing Scrutiny

Luis Carrillo, an attorney for Lopez’s family, praised the potential decertification, stating it could prevent the officers from harming the community further. However, some critics believe this case is isolated.

POST spokesperson Meagan Poulos emphasized that the decision is based on the specific evidence presented in this case. The outcome is expected to influence future cases involving disputed use of force by law enforcement.