Dave Portnoy Revises Long Island Pizza Opinion

Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy has significantly upgraded his assessment of Long Island pizza following positive reviews of Mike’s Underground Pizza in Amityville (8.1) and Nico’s Charred Pies in Copiague (8.2) during his ‘One Bite Pizza Reviews’ tour.

Challenging Previous Criticisms

Dave Portnoy, known for his brutally honest pizza reviews, recently toured Long Island pizzerias. He previously characterized Long Island pizza as consistently floppy and doughy, a critique that sparked debate among local pizza fans. His recent visits aimed to challenge these long-held opinions.

Impressive Scores at Mike’s Underground Pizza

At Mike’s Underground Pizza in Amityville, Portnoy stated, “I've spent a couple years trashing Long Island pizza, because I said it’s floppy, it’s doughy and everyone's like, oh Long Island, but I haven't had any -- this is very good.” He awarded the pizzeria an 8.1 out of 10.

Unique Delivery Service

Mike’s Underground Pizza operates with a unique model, handling all orders directly via text message or through their own delivery staff. For customers outside their immediate delivery area, they offer a distinctive service: a formally dressed waiter delivers the pizza to a pre-arranged location.

Nico’s Charred Pies Earns High Marks

Portnoy continued his tour at Nico’s Charred Pies in Copiague, awarding them a stellar rating of 8.2. This score places Nico’s among the highest-rated pizzerias on his ‘One Bite’ platform.

A Potential Turning Point

These back-to-back positive reviews suggest a shift in Portnoy’s perception of Long Island pizza. This could inspire others to explore the region’s diverse culinary offerings. The reviews occurred alongside Earth Day observances focused on healthy eating, highlighting contrasting food culture preferences.

Long Island Weather Update

Scattered showers were reported across Long Island, but forecasts predicted clearing conditions and warmer temperatures by Thursday. This offers a welcome change for outdoor activities.