“That Friend,” a comedy debuting at the 2026 Tribeca Film Festival, follows two estranged pals, Henry (Josh Brener) and Paul (Harvey Guillén), whose reunion spirals into chaos when Paul crashes Henry’s romantic getaway. Despite the relatable set‑up, critics say the jokes never land and the film’s tone wavers between irritation and drama.

Alex Wall and Will Sterling’s 87‑Minute Misfire

Directors Alex Wall and Will Sterling, who also wrote and produced the film, delivered an 87‑minute runtime that struggles to balance humor with heartfelt moments, according to the festival review. the duo’s ambition to blend comedy with the “eroding friendships and relationship growing pains” theme is evident, but the execution leaves the audience unsure of the intended emotional payoff.

Harvey Guillén’s Paul Generates Irritation, Not Laughter

Harvey Guillén’s portrayal of the eccentric friend Paul is described as more aggravating than amusing, with his antics—including a baffling subplot about acid‑laced cigarettes—failing to elicit laughs. The review notes that Guillén’s performance “genertaes more irritation than laughter,” underscoring a core flaw in the film’s comedic core.

Billie Lourd’s Penny and the Unfulfilled Romantic Getaway

Billie Lourd appears as Penny, Henry’s girlfriend, whose presence should have heightened the romantic tension but instead highlights the film’s uneven tone.. While the premise of a friend crashing a getaway feels instantly relatable, the narrative never fully capitalises on that tension, leaving the romantic subplot underdeveloped.

Mixed Reception to the Brave Yet Flawed Ending

The film concludes with a daring, unconventional finale that attempts to subvert expectations, yet critics argue it “doesn’t fully earn” its boldness. This mixed ending reflects the broader pattern of missed opportunities throughout the movie, where dramatic beats briefly engage but are quickly undermined by weak humor.

Who’s Missing From the Conversation?

The review does not include audience reactions or comments from the film’s producers, leaving unanswered whether Wall and Sterling plan to re‑edit the cut for a wider release on June 8, 2026. additionally, the impact of supporting cast members such as Retta and Levi Chambers remains unaddressed, raising questions about their contributions to the film’s limited success.