Sylvester Stallone is currently navigating a massive divide between critical reception and commercial success. While his new action thriller Alarum holds a 0% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, the film has simultaneously climbed into the top ten most-watched titles on Amazon Prime Video.
The 0% Rotten Tomatoes score that failed to stop Prime Video viewership
Stallone is experiencing a bizarre professional dichotomy in late 2026. According to a recent report, his action thriller Alarum has achieved a rare 0% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes while simultaneously securing a spot in the top ten most-watched films on Amazon Prime Video as of November 7,2026. This phenomenon reflects a broader shift in the streaming era where engagement metrics often supersede traditional reviews.
As the report notes, algorithmic promotion and subscriber engagement are increasingly overriding the consensus of professional critics. This suggests that for major platforms, the ability to capture a viewer's attention is becoming more valuable than the qualitative assessment of the content itself.
Jeff Ewing’s 3/10 critique of the Eastwood and Colter ensemble
The critical backlash against Alarum has been significant. Collider reviewer Jeff Ewing issued a scathing 3/10 review, describing the project as an "undercooked concept" that fails to utilize its talent. Despite a cast that includes Scott Eastwood and Mike Colter, Ewing argued that even committed performances could not salvage the film's narrative shortcomings.
This disconnect highlights a growing tension in modern Hollywood, where a talented ensemble can be effectively wasted on a premise that lacks coherence , yet still find a massive audience through platform visibility.
Tulsa King’s 86% approval rating on Paramount+
In stark contrast to the failure of Alarum, Stallone’s television work remains a critical darling. Tulsa King, which follows the character Dwight Manfredi, has maintained a dominant presence on Paramount+. the fourth season of the series has achieved a much more favorable 86% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, bolstered by the addition of series regulars Flula Borg and Gretchen Mol.
This success highlights Stallone's ability to maintain high engagement across different platforms, even when his film work fails to meet critical standards.. The series continues to serve as a flagship program for the network, proving his enduring versatility.
The battle between South Park and Dwight Manfredi for top spots
The competition for viewership on Paramount+ remains fierce, as Tulsa King frequently battles the long-running animated series South Park for the number one spot. This competition underscores the high stakes of streaming dominance, where flagship programs must fight for every minute of attention to maintain their ranking.
Who is actually driving the massive viewership for Alarum?
While the viewership numbers for Alarum are undeniable, several questions remain regarding the specific drivers of this success. It is currently unverified whether the high engagement is driven by Stallone's massive fan base or if Amazon Prime Video's algorithms are aggressively pushing the film to users regardless of its quality. Additionally, the report does not specify if the high viewership is due to a high number of unique viewers or simply high completion rates from a dedicated core audience.
Comments 0