Brendan Cole, the first-ever champion of Strictly Come Dancing, is facing a fresh wave of public backlash following critical remarks about Amy Dowden. the former professional dancer, known for his volatile tenure on the show, has once again drawn fire for questioning a colleague's performance levels.
The 'not up to the challenge' remark regarding Amy Dowden
The latest controversy centers on Brendan Cole's public assessment of Amy Dowden, who recently returned to the spotlight after a battle with cancer. According to the report, the 50-year-old Cole stated that Dowden had not reached the necessary level to compete, explicitly describing her performance as "not up to the challenge."
This critique was not well-received by his peers, most notably James Jordan. As the report says, Jordan claimed that Brendan Cole had significantly over-exaggerated his criticisms, fueling a public debate over whether Cole is acting out of professional passion or has simply become a "bitter old pro." Cole has defended his stance, arguing that his bluntness is a byproduct of his commitment to dance excellence.
Fourteen years of friction and the 2018 exit
Brendan Cole's current status as an outsider is the culmination of a career defined by conflict. After joining Strictly Come Dancing in 2004, Cole spent 14 years as a central figure on the program, but his time there was marked by frequent clashes with the judging panel.. The report highlights notable altercations with Bruno Tonioli and Shirley Ballas, the latter of whom publicly criticized Cole's choreography.
These recurring tensions eventually led to Cole being axed from the seris in 2018. The report notes that his departure followed allegations that he was difficult to work with and that his relationship with head judge Shirley Ballas had deteriorated beyond repair. Despite his exit, Cole has continued to critique the show, suggesting in a 2021 interview that the production only showcased a narrow, contentious slice of his personality.
Strained bonds with Fiona Phillips, Claire King, and Lulu
Beyond the judges, Brendan Cole's demanding coaching style often left his celebrity partners feeling alienated. The report identifies several high-profile pairings—including TV presenter Fiona Phillips, actress Claire King, and singer Lulu—who felt undervalued or overly challenged by Cole's approach. Cole himself has been candid about these frictions, at times labeling some of his partners as "rough" or "unloved."
This pattern of behavior suggests a fundamental disconnect between Cole's rigorous professional standards and the supportive environment typically expected in celebrity dance competitions . By criticizing partners in the press , Brendan Cole cemented a reputation for volatility that often overshadowed his technical skill as a dancer.
How the 'bad boy' persona fueled Strictly's early drama
The trajectory of Brendan Cole's career reflects a broader trend in reality television where producers lean into personality clashes to drive viewership. in the early years of Strictly Come Dancing, Cole's fiery temperament provided a dynamic narrative foil to the more reserved contestants, making him a favorite for audiences who craved ballroom drama.
However, the shift in contemporary broadcasting toward empathy and mental health awareness has made Cole's "bad boy" archetype less palatable... The tension between the desire for "dynamic storytelling" and the protection of professional reputations is a persistent challenge for reality show producers, as seen in the way Cole was eventually phased out of the franchise.
Whether James Jordan's rebuttal marks a turning point for Cole's public image
While the report details the backlash from James Jordan, it leaves several questions unanswered. It remains unclear if other current Strictly Come Dancing professionals view Cole's comments on Amy Dowden as a breach of professional etiquette or merely a continuation of his established brand. Furthermore, the source does not clarify if the Strictly production team has issued a formal response to Cole's recent criticisms.
There is also the question of whether Brendan Cole is attempting to maintain a presence in the dance world through strategic controversy. Without a current role on the show, his public critiques of figures like Amy Dowden may be the only remaining tool he has to stay relevant in the conversation surrounding the franchise.
Comments 0