Sarah Pidgeon and Paul Anthony Kelly, stars of the acclaimed anthology series Love Story, made a striking appearance together at the 2026 Met Gala in New York City.

A Reunion on the Red Carpet

The event marked a reunion for the pair, who recently captivated audiences with their portrayals of Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy and John F. Kennedy Jr. respectively. Pidgeon, 29, showcased a radiant look, departing from her on-screen character’s typically understated style with a vibrant yellow dress featuring a dramatic bow detail and a high-waisted skirt.

She completed the ensemble with minimal accessories and classic makeup, allowing her blonde hair to flow freely. Kelly, 37, complemented her with a sophisticated ensemble of black trousers, a dark red velvet jacket, and a crisp white shirt.

The Impact of 'Love Story'

The duo’s presence at the Met Gala comes after their roles in Love Story generated significant buzz, though not without controversy. The FX/Hulu series, which premiered on February 12th and concluded on March 26th, quickly became FX’s most-streamed limited series, amassing an impressive 65 million hours of viewership across Hulu and Disney+.

Critical Reception and Controversy

While critics generally praised the show, awarding it an 81% score on Rotten Tomatoes, some, including close friends of Bessette-Kennedy and JFK Jr.’s nephew Jack Schlossberg, expressed dissatisfaction with its depiction of the iconic couple. Concerns centered around historical inaccuracies and a perceived lack of consultation with the Kennedy family.

Pidgeon's Dedication to the Role

Despite the criticism, Pidgeon has spoken extensively about her dedication to portraying Bessette-Kennedy with sensitivity and accuracy, emphasizing her desire to reveal the woman behind the fashion icon. Pidgeon’s performance has even sparked early Emmy nomination buzz, according to The Hollywood Reporter.

The actress shared that the initial online reactions to the series underscored the importance of honoring Bessette-Kennedy’s legacy. She aimed to portray a more nuanced and complete picture of the often-misunderstood figure, highlighting her vivacious personality and hidden depths.

A Star-Studded Event

Kelly, meanwhile, maintained a composed demeanor on the red carpet, posing for photographs alongside his co-star and other prominent celebrities like Nicole Kidman and Lauren Sanchez. The show featured a talented ensemble cast including Grace Gummer, Naomi Watts, Alessandro Nivola, Leila George, Sydney Lemmon and Constance Zimmer.

The Met Gala appearance serves as a further testament to the impact of Love Story and the rising star power of both Pidgeon and Kelly, solidifying their positions as captivating talents in the entertainment industry.