Blake Lively's Sexual Harassment Claims Partially Dismissed

A New York federal judge has issued a partial ruling in the case brought by actress Blake Lively against actor Justin Baldoni, stemming from their work on the film 'It Ends With Us'. Judge Lewis J. Liman dismissed Lively’s sexual harassment claims on Thursday, but permitted two retaliation claims to proceed to a jury trial.

Background of the Lawsuit

Lively initially filed a lawsuit in December 2024, outlining over a dozen claims against Baldoni and other involved parties. The trial is currently scheduled to begin on May 18th, following a phone conference to discuss jury selection. Justin Baldoni has consistently denied all allegations of sexual harassment.

Judge's Reasoning for Dismissal

Independent Contractor Status

The judge’s decision to dismiss the sexual harassment claims was largely based on Lively’s status as an independent contractor, rather than an employee. This meant she wasn’t protected under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits employment discrimination.

Context of Film Acting

Judge Liman considered the context of film acting when evaluating the alleged incidents. He acknowledged that certain behaviors, such as Baldoni allegedly leaning in and making physical contact, would likely be considered a hostile work environment in a typical employment setting.

However, the judge determined that these actions were not significantly beyond what could reasonably be expected between characters during a film scene. He emphasized the need to allow creative artists space for experimentation without fear of liability.

Retaliation Claims to Proceed

Preserved Claims

Despite dismissing the harassment claims, the judge allowed two retaliation claims to move forward – one against It Ends With Us Movie LLC and Wayfarer Studios, and a third claim of breach of contract rider agreement. This ensures a jury will hear allegations related to the alleged retaliation Lively experienced after seeking a safer work environment.

Statements from Involved Parties

Blake Lively expressed gratitude for the court’s ruling and stated her intention to fully share her story at trial, for herself and others. Attorneys for Justin Baldoni expressed satisfaction with the dismissal of the sexual harassment claims, stating the case had been significantly narrowed.

Lively’s attorney confirmed the case will remain focused on the alleged retaliation and efforts to damage Lively’s reputation. The trial is expected to provide further insight into the allegations and their impact.