Hugh Jackman faced criticism from some fans after posting an affectionate Instagram photo with girlfriend Sutton Foster at the New York premiere of his new film 'The Death of Robin Hood' on Thursday. The image, showing the 57-year-old actor with his arm around the 51-year-old Foster, drew comments questioning the relationship and expressing sympathy for his ex-wife Deborra-Lee Furness, with whom Jackman finalized his divorce in June after 27 years of marriage. The post, captioned 'And we're off to the premiere of Death of Robin Hood,' was shot at AMC Lincoln Square 13.

The Premiere Photo That Sparked a Fan Revolt

The photograph Jackman shared from the Thursday premiere immediately ignited a polarized response on Instagram. According to the source article, one commenter wrote, 'I see your pics I think of how heartbroken Deb must be,' while another called the image 'cringy.' A third user bluntly said, 'Bro, stop posting pictures with her. Literally no one supports this relationship.' Some fans even pledged to boycott his future work: 'My hubby of 40 years even said for the first time of any celebrity break up that he would never, ever watch anything you are in again!'

These critical remarks coexisted with a wave of supportive messages. One fan declared, 'I love that you two are together. Two of my Broadway faves - what could be better than that?!' Another argued, 'Anyone complaining is just upset that soulmates aren't a real thing.' The source notes that similar backlash had already surfaced after Jackman attended the Met Gala with Foster the previous month, a venue he had historically frequented with Furness.

Why Deborra-Lee Furness Remains Central to the Narrative

The debate over Jackman's new relationship cannot be understood without the shadow of his 27-year marriage to Furness. the source says the couple separated roughly a year before Jackman confirmed his romance with Foster in January 2025. Fans' persistent references to Furness — her 'heartbreak' and the perceived speed of the transition — reveal how deeply the public had invested in that union. As the report noted, the divorce was finalized only in June, and the timeline has fueled speculation about overlapping relationships.

This pattern echoees broader celebrity trends: when a long-married figure moves on publicly, audiences often demand explanations or express loyalty to the former spouse. For Jackman, who built much of his wholesome image around his marriage, the new romance challenges that carefully curated brand.

The Met Gala Debut and a No-Prenup Report

Foster and Jackman's joint appearance at the Met Gala last month was widely interpreted as a definitive confirmation of their relationship. The source says that Jackman had attended the 2024 gala alone and skipped the 2025 event during the separation. Their debut together, combined with a February report from The Globe claiming Jackman had declined to request a prenuptial agreement from Foster, has fueled wedding speculation. However, the source does not independently verify that claim — it is a tabloid rumor that remains unconfirmed. What is clear is that the couple is not shying away from high-profile events, which invites both celebration and scrutiny.

'The Death of Robin Hood': Jackman's New Film Amid Personal Spotlight

Jackman stars as the titular outlaw in 'The Death of Robin Hood,' a film described as following a weary Robin Hood, gravely wounded after a battle, who encounters a mysterious woman offering a path to redemption. The film also features Jodie Comer, Bill Skarsgård, Jade Croot, and Katie Breen. the promotional push for this project has inevitably become intertwined with Jackman's personal life, as each public appearance — from the premiere to the Met Gala — attracts commentary that blurs the line between actor and character. The source reports that the consistent criticism suggests a segment of the fanbase remains unreconciled to the new relationship, even as Jackman moves forward professionally.