The $96% Rotten Tomatoes Score That Wasn't Enough

Despite earning a near-perfect Rotten Tomatoes score of 96% and Stephen King's stamp of approval, the CBS-turned-Paramount+ series Evil was canceled after four seasons .

The show's unique blend of procedural and supernatural elements, reminiscent of shows like Mindhunter and The Exorcist, made it a standout in the horror genre.

However, its declining viewership eventually led to its cancellation, leaving fans to wonder what could have been.

A Procedural Approach to the Supernatural

Evil's portrayal of dark supernatural forces through the lens of behavioral science added a layer of depth to the show, making it more than just a horror series.

The show's adoption of a procedural and bureaucratic approach to investigating 'monsters' blurred the lines between psychopathy and genuine supernatural possession.

This approach, reminiscent of by-the-books crime thriller detective shows like Mindhunter, made the series feel both intellectually stimulating and terrifying.

The 'Monster of the Week' Format

Evil's reliance on a 'monster of the week' format allowed it to pick on a diverse set of horror tropes, making each episode feel fresh and exciting.

However, this format also meant that the show's narrative was often fragmented, with each episode feeling like a self-contained story rather than part of a larger arc.

Despite this,the show's ability to balance procedural elements with supernatural plot twists made it a compelling watch.

A Legacy Cut Short

Even Stephen King expressed his love for the series , calling it great, funny, witty, and very, very sharp.

However, despite garnering such high praise, Evil did not get a second chance, and its chances of revival are starting to diminish.

It is disappointing that the show will probably never get to reach its natural conclusion , but its four available seasons tell well-rounded and satisfying stories that viewers can still enjoy .