Director James Watkins has confired that the upcoming DCU Clayface film will not feature Batman. By focusing on the transformation of actor Matt Hagen, the production aims to tell a singular, character-focused story within the sprawling metropolis of Gotham.

Advertisement

The "Joker" Blueprint for Matt Hagen’s Tragedy

James Watkins intends to treat the Clayface film as a standalone character study rather than a traditional superhero spectacle. As reported by the source,Watkins cited Todd Phillips’ Joker as his primary inspiration, aiming to tell the story of one individual—Matt Hagen—amidst a city of millions. This approach moves away from the vigilante-centric narratives that usually define the DC Universe.

The film follows Matt Hagen, an aspiring Hollywood actor whose life is upended after a mobster causes him horrific disfigurement following a drunken night out. By centering the narrative on Hagen's personal descent,Watkins hopes to avoid the "cute" tropes often found in superhero cinema.. Instead of a battle between hero and villain, the focus remains on the psychological and physical toll taken on Hagen himself.

1930s German Expressionism and the Oppressive Streets of Gotham

The visual identity of the film relies heavily on an opppressive atmosphere designed by production designer James Price and cinematographer Rob Hardy. According to the report, Price—an Oscar winner for Poor Things—and Watkins utilized 1930s German expressionist techniques to make the architecture of Gotham feel as though it is looming over the characters. This design chhoice is intended to make the city itself feel like a living, breathing antagonist.

To capture the "dirty poetry" of the city, the crew drew inspiration from the grit of New York City during the 1970s, 80s, and 90s. this aesthetic choice includes a deliberate effort to frame out the sky, ensuring that the audience feels the claustrophobia of Gotham. Watkins even studied various iterations of the city, from the dayglow palettes of Joel Schumacher to the grounded realism of Christopher Nolan and the stylized worlds of Tim Burton. This visual journey begins in the sun-drenched, greenery-filled Coast City before descending into the dark, neon-lit streets of Gotham.

Can a Gotham Without Batman Sustain the DCU's Momentum?

While the production has secured a cast including Tom Rhys Harries and Max Minghella, several questions remain regarding the film's place in the broader DC Universe. The source does not clarify how the absence of Batman will impact the film's connection to future DCU installments, nor does it detail how the GCPD, played by Minghella, will interact with a city that lacks its primary protector. Furthermore, it remains to be seen if a story focused solely on a disfigured actor can satisfy audiences accustomed to high-stakes superhero battles, despite the "pinch me moments" expressed by the cast.