A London High Court judge has ordered the removal of all Wolfoo videos after finding that SConnect, the Vietnamese creator, stole audio from Peppa Pig. The ruling protects the interests of Hasbro and Astley Baker Davies Ltd. across 166 World Trade Organisation member nations.
The 92 English-language videos that proved audio theft
The legal victory for Hasbro and Astley Baker Davies Ltd. hinged on a strategic pivot in their evidence. While the plaintiffs initially focused on the visual similarities between the characters, they shifted their case to focus on audio clips. According to the report,this move proved decisive as it provided a more concrete way to demonstrate that content had been lifted directly from the British show.
Mr Justice Smith found the evidence of audio copying to be "compelling," noting that the practice was extensive and endemic. The court examined a sample of 92 English-language Wolfoo videos, finding infringing audio in every single one. Furthermore, the report says that approximately three-quarters of the foreign-language videos examined also contained stolen audio clips from Peppa Pig.
SConnect's failed third-party contractor defense
In its defense, SConnect denied the copyright infringement claims but admitted that some videos produced before mid-2020 utilized Peppa Pig audio. The Vietnamese firm argued that an independent third-party contractor was responsible for the theft without the company's knowledge. SConnect further claimed that all animations created after mid-2020 used only in-house voices and sounds.
Mr Justice Smith rejected these arguments, stating that the involvement of a third party was "irrelevant" to the fact of the infringement. The judge also noted that while some infringing content had been deleted, other videos were simply shifted to different channels to avoid detection. additionally, the court found that SConnect's claim regarding the use of exclusively in-house audio after 2020 could be "disproved."
A single UK ruling covering 166 WTO states
This case represents a significant tactical win for intellectual property holders fighting "content farms" and clones in the digital age. By bringing the suit in London, the legal team from Brandsmiths was able to leverage the defendants' activity within the United Kingdom to secure a sweeping judgment. As reported, this allows Hasbro and Astley Baker Davies Ltd. to protect the Peppa Pig brand in one forum rather than litigating in every individual country where the content was viewed.
The scope of the ruling is remarkably broad, applying to all 166 World Trade Organisation states , including the US, EU, UK, and Vietnam. This mirrors a growing trend where global brands seek centralized judicial remedies to combat the viral spread of derivative or "imposter" content that targets young children, specifically those aged between two and five, who may not distinguish between official and unofficial characters.
The 4pm BST deadline and the fate of Wolfoo's views
The immediate consequence of the ruling is a strict ultimatum: Mr Justice Smith ordered that all videos featuring Wolfoo must be taken down before 4pm BST on Monday. This order targets the entire library of the character, not just the specific samples examined during the trial, despite SConnect's attempts to limit the ruling's scope.
However, several points remain unverified. The report does not specify whether SConnect faces significant financial penalties or damages beyond the takedown order. It also remains unclear how the court intends to enforce the Monday deadline across all 166 WTO states, particularly within Vietnam, given the decentralized nature of online video hosting.
Comments 0